By Chuck Flint, AIA CEO
As a new Congress prepares to take the reins in Washington, a familiar argument is making its return: Give the IRS more money, and taxpayers will get better service. Americans have heard that promise before, and they remember how it turned out.
Taxpayer service was already failing under the Biden administration. In 2021, nearly nine in ten calls to the IRS went unanswered, according to the National Taxpayer Advocate, and in 2022, it got worse. Callers who managed to reach a representative waited an average of 29 minutes on hold, up from 23 minutes the year before.
And the phone lines were only part of the problem. The agency ended 2021 with 4.7 million unprocessed returns, and responding to a proposed change to a return took more than eight months on average in FY2022. These were not the failures of an agency short on auditors. They were the failures of an agency not serving American taxpayers, who it exists to serve.
That was the state of the agency when Democrats passed the Inflation Reduction Act and sold it as relief for frustrated taxpayers. Instead, Washington found about $46 billion to expand enforcement, more than half of the law’s roughly $80 billion for the IRS. Taxpayer services got about $3.2 billion. While Americans struggled to get someone on the phone, the IRS hired a new army of auditors.
Without clear plans for accountability, why should taxpayers trust that the outcome will be different this time around? In fact, the data already indicates that they won't. In a national poll AIA released this year, 53% of Americans rated IRS customer service negatively, and 78% said the IRS should be held to measurable customer service standards and performance goals.
Before Congress sends the IRS another dollar, it should demand clear service standards, public reporting on whether the agency meets them, and consequences when it does not. The IRS is there to serve taxpayers. It should not be judged by how aggressively it pursues them, but by how well it serves them.